Top NewsHungary files charges against 98-year-old war crimes suspect Csatáry [13]
September 13th, 2012

Former MDF party leader Dávid acquitted in phone tapping suit

The Kuria, Hungary’s supreme court, has upheld a lower court acquittal of Ibolya David, the former leader of the now defunct MDF party, in a case dating back to 2008 involving private secret security firm UD.

At a press conference in 2008, David said that people associated with UD had attempted to interfere with internal affairs of her former party, and released secretly recorded telephone conversations as evidence. The persons David named at the time sued her on grounds of their right to privacy, while the public prosecutor also raised charges against the party leader.

In April, a lower court already acquitted David, and former Socialist minister in charge of the secret services Gyorgy Szilvassy, another suspect in the case, but the prosecutor appealed the verdict.

The prosecutor had accused Szilvasy, David and two others, Karoly Herenyi, the MDF deputy leader, and Karoly Toth, the one-time Socialist deputy chairman of the national security committee, of making public secretly recorded telephone conversations between then opposition Fidesz politicians Laszlo Kover, the current House Speaker, Ervin Demeter, a one-time minister in charge of the secret services, and Jozsef Horvath, one of the heads of UD, thereby violating their basic rights.

Visit www.hungarymatters.hu to receive Hungarian news agency MTI’s twice-daily newsletter.
Topics
Share
  • MagyarViking

    FINALLY!!!

    We should all collect money a BIG bottle of Pezsgő for them
    And a fond to cover the legal costs for people charged with ‘Anti-Orban’ crimes, because this is what it was

    This is the legal end of a long power struggle by PimpMaster Whorban to totally crush the Hungarian Conservative party MDF and replace it with His own brand of Hungarian National Populism

    Long Live David – Disgrace For PimpMaster Whorban!

  • Aloof

    I wish she could sue the crap out of everyone regarding this very sordid Fidesz fiasco, especially UD Zrt and everyone connected with Budapest Analyses but Fidesz already covered their butt the same day the lower court ruled in her favor along with Toth, Herenyi and Szilvassy back in May;

    “UD Zrt. also sued the National Security Office and the Hungarian state for 1.8 billion forints claiming damages to the owners’ personal reputations. Yesterday, on the very same day Szilvássy and Tóth were found not guilty, the Hungarian state agreed on a full settlement. UD Zrt., a company that was illegally spying on the Hungarian National Security Office and other branches of the government, will receive 1.8 billion forints of taxpayer money in compensation!! I’m sure they will be appropriately grateful to Fidesz.” Incredibly corrupt and dirty business indeed…

  • olga

    @ Viking

    I don’t know what all the issues In the David matter nor does it matter to me in this particular case but it sounds like the Court’s decision shows the the independence of the judiciary

    What would you be writing if the Supreme Court overturned the Lower Court’s decision ?

    • MagyarViking

      olga says:
      September 13, 2012 at 3:33 pm

      it sounds like the Court’s decision shows the the independence of the judiciary

      Yes, but remember ‘leto’s’ main judicial argument –
      * ‘there are too many communist judges’

      What I would have written if she had lost?
      Do not know in details, but something about pursuing it
      in an European Court, then I think she was totally correct

      Of course, she could also have been convicted on some legal technicality, but now they did not even manage to catch her on that

      I do not think I would have claimed that the judges would have bowed for political pressure, because I do not think the Hungarian Judiciary do in general and especially not the Supreme and Constitutional Courts

      I have though not always agreed with all the rulings of these two courts, but what the heck, I am no lawyer…

      The killing of Ságvári Endre and to allow the Fidesz referendum on the 300 HUF doctor fee, are the two cases where I do not understand/agree with their decisions
      I think both rulings go contradictory to common sense

  • Aloof

    In this case it was pretty much a moot point once the lower court awarded UD Zrt 1.8 BN HUF in a \settlement\ the same day they cut Ibolya David loose. That closed the loop for Fidesz on the case.

    OV destroyed her for costing him the 2006 election and eliminated conservative MDF. I hope she goes back into politics, I’d vote for her.

More content from Hungary's leading foreign-language media network
About Politics.hu | Become an All Hungary Member | Newsletters | Contact Us | Advertise With Us
All content © 2004-2013 The All Hungary Media Group. Articles, comments and other information on the All Hungary Media Group's network of sites are provided "as is" without guarantees, warranties, or representations of any kind, and the opinions and views expressed in such articles and columns are not necessarily those of the All Hungary Media Group.